

The panel largely sided with Corellium on whether its copying of iOS code was transformative, a question posed by the second factor under the four-factor fair use doctrine. “Corellium created a new product with new features.” “Corellium invented a creative and innovative tool that furthered the very creative progress that copyright seeks to achieve,” the panel said. The appeals court said the case looks a lot like a 2015 ruling from the Second Circuit in Authors Guild v. upholding the legality of the Google Book Project, which scanned millions of books into a searchable online database. In that case, Google’s database was deemed transformative because it “augmented public knowledge” by providing information about millions of books, such as the frequency of usage of certain words across time.ĬORSEC allows researchers to monitor iOS processes in real time and run experiments. “There’s no dispute that these features assist researchers and enable them to do their work in new ways,” the court said. The US Supreme Court is currently considering a case that will further clarify transformative use in Andy Warhol Foundation v. The panel said the question of whether CORSEC served as a market substitute for Apple’s own security research products was a “somewhat closer question.” Still, Apple doesn’t have a monopoly “over transformative research tools that supply information about its operating system,” the court said.Ĭircuit Judges Elizabeth Branch and Andrew Luck, and District Judge Louis Sands sat on the panel. Latham & Watkins LLP and Lash & Goldberg LLP represent Apple. Goldstein & Russell PC, Hecht Partners LLP, Cole Scott & Kissane PA, and Reid Collins & Tsai LLP represent Corellium. 21-12835, 5/8/23.You don't have to be a professional filmmaker to create compelling and visually pleasing video content. You just need to find the right video editing software. Many business owners have already had great success in using video content on social media, their websites, and email marketing to advertise their products and services. Video remains one of the top ways to engage followers and promote your brand.

Smartphones and tablets make shooting video content relatively affordable however, editing your video is another matter entirely. Many video editing tools are complicated and time-consuming to learn.

To help you find the right video editing software, we’ve compiled a list of well-regarded and intuitive options to help you create beautiful, professional-looking video content for your business. Headliner is an easy way to add captions or text to your video.

Since many followers watch video on the go, adding captions enables them to engage with your content without disturbing everyone around them.
